âI thought it was suspicious, so I decided to inform the knight commander about it first. He was getting ready to go out but he came back for a while, and I was about to tell him about Miss Charlotte when he entered the room, but then the commander was very flustered when he noticed that his gold brooch had disappeared. It looks like itâs very precious to the commander because he usually pins it on his overcoatâŠâ
ââŠâŠâ
âAfter seeing what I saw, I think it was Miss Charlotte who took it. I saw Miss Charlotte enter the knight commanderâs room before it disappeared, thatâs whyâŠ! Miss Charlotte isnât acquainted with the commander and sheâs not assigned to the knightsâ quarters, yet she entered the commanderâs room⊠T-Thatâs why I thought she was suspicious.â
After prattling out her explanation while she continued to look visibly nervous, Serena hurriedly lowered her head the moment her gaze met mine.
Anyone who had eyes could see that she seemed to have no talent for lying.
With a sharp tone, I asked Serena directly.
âSo youâre saying that youâre the only witness, but whoâs to say that you arenât the thief here? It looks terribly like youâre falsely accusing Charlotte to cover up your own tracks. How can I believe your words?â
âB-But, Iâmââ
âIn the first place, Charlotte is a lady-in-waiting, and compared to a maid like you, she has a higher wage. Tell me, who between the two of you is the more likely to be tempted by the commanderâs brooch? If you do just a bit of critical thinking, youâd be able to guess the answer, yes?â
âNo, Madam! I didnât steal it! R-Really, IâŠ!â
âIf you really didnât steal it, then itâs fine if we conduct a search, right?â
âB-ButâŠâ
âLily, thatâs enough. Serena isââ
When I cornered Serena, just as expected, Missus Seymour stepped in. But I cut her off and asked back.
âMissus Seymour, have you tried searching these people? Shouldnât that be done first?â
Missus Seymourâs expression slipped for a moment as she pretended to be unaffected, but she immediately answered calmly.
ââŠI didnât think that there was a need to cause such a commotion. Thereâs a witness here, so that should be enough.â
âI donât know about that. Isnât it very possible for anyone to claim and pretend theyâre a witness? Letâs start with the people who are already here. Except for Charlotte, youâre all assigned to the knightsâ quarters, correct?â
To answer my question, one lady-in-waiting and two maids nodded blankly in surprise. They had never seen me act like this before.
I looked elsewhereâtowards Serena, who had turned as white as a sheet, and the other maid, who continued to stand still while expressionless this whole time.
At first glance, that maid looked like she was entirely calm. But once I looked at her closely, I could see how she kept picking at the sides of one fingernail, blood slowly trickling out from the fresh wound.
I approached that maid and asked her.
âWhy is your hand like that?â
ââŠâŠ!â
The maid flinched noticeably, as if she didnât expect me to ask that question at all.
She looked at me with eyes that went as wide as saucers, hurriedly hiding both hands behind her as she stammered.
âI-Itâs, just, itâs⊠a habitâŠâ
âYouâll have to correct all your bad habits before you can become a lady-in-waiting later, wonât you?â
And right on cue, Missus Seymour interfered once again.
âLily, I donât think this childâs habits matter at the moment.â
âYes, Missus Seymour, youâre right. So letâs hurry up and do a body search for all the people here.â
âDo we really need to do that? Iâm more curious about why Charlotte Brandon entered the knight commanderâs room.â
âActually, Missus Seymour, she did that because I told her to.â
When Missus Seymour spoke, she had a smile on her lips. But now, as she heard my answer, her eyebrows wriggled.
âDonât you think itâs strange for Charlotte to steal a gold brooch like that when she went to the knight commanderâs room under my order? Itâs not just anyone elseâs orderâitâs mine, the Duchessâ. By chance, will you say that I ordered her to steal that brooch? Or perhaps, do you think that she impulsively pocketed it in there? She didnât exactly enter that room without anyone knowing. She went there because I gave her an order to do so, didnât she?â
ââŠâŠâ
Missus Seymourâs eyes were blazing with fury. But regardless of that, I turned to the three maids and two ladies-in-waiting.
âNow, come forward, letâs search you one by one. Or whoever did it, just come forward and confess before the search. If you do that, Iâll spare you from any corporeal punishment.â
However, no one admitted anything, so the search eventually commenced.
The search was conducted by Charlotte. Missus Seymour glared at me with blazing eyes, but at that moment, Charlotte paused when she took off one of Serenaâs socks.
âOh, thisâŠâ
As her left foot was raised, Serena remained frozen and speechless. Her face was completely pale.
The gold brooch slipped out the sock.
She was walking so strangely because the brooch was hidden in her sock.
Serena stumbled back and soon collapsed to the floor. I already expected it, but her conviction really was weak.
And I already knew the answer, but I still asked.
âSerena, did you steal it?â
âN-NoâŠâ
Her shoulders shook as her lips opened and closed. Tears welled up in Serenaâs eyes as she shook her head vigorously, as if she really was innocent.
When she was about to say something, the unmannered lady-in-waiting stepped forward and shouted.
âYou! Youâre the one who stole it, but you tried to pin it on someone else?! You also stole Lucyâs silver earrings last time, too, didnât you? Your younger siblings must be so proud of how youâre making a living!â
The situation started irrationally, and this time, too, it would end irrationally. And it seemed like the most irrational person here was the one who characteristically had no self-awareness.
As that lady-in-waiting pointed at Serena, her finger was shaking.
I grasped that hand and held it still. Shocked by this, the lady-in-waiting turned to me.
With a somewhat bored tone, I said,
âStop it, Ayla. Itâs no use. Unfortunately for you, even if you sell the knight commanderâs gold brooch⊠No. Actually, no matter what else you steal, you wonât be able to settle all of your loverâs debts.â
âWhat, w-what are youâŠâ
This lady-in-waitingâs name was Ayla.
I had quite the laundry list of the disgraces of each and every servant working in this household.